Skip to content
Open access · OA via OpenAlex

The carbohydrate debate: what is best for patients with diabetes?

Ken Shaw

Practical Diabetes · 2003

Abstract

The April 2003 Royal College of Physicians Nutrition Committee Report on Obesity prompted the headline media caption ‘More than half of adults are too fat and getting fatter’. Over the last two decades obesity has increased threefold, with over 55% of the UK population now considered seriously overweight, resulting in many adverse health consequences including the dramatic rise in type 2 diabetes. The media obsession with body image and weight never ceases. Almost daily, new dietary strategies are declared, promising success and satisfaction. Such has been the remarkable popularity of Dr Robert Atkins' Diet Revolution, first published in 1972, promoting the simplistic concept that dietary carbohydrate of all kind was the main determinant of adverse glucose metabolism, inappropriate stimulation of insulin secretion and thereby undue weight gain. Dr Atkins, who had advocated his diet from personal example, died on the 17 April 2003, at the age of 72 following an accidental head injury. His books sold many millions of copies, but how successful has his Diet Revolution proved? As with other popular diets, will the enthusiasm diminish now that the principal charismatic proponent has departed? With this debate we present two personal case histories – one from a person with type 2 and the other with type 1 diabetes – both of whom are convinced they have benefited from this type of diet. Details of significant improvement in measures of metabolic control and parallel reduction in prescribed medication are provided. These individual accounts are submitted to encourage debate. Such radical dietary approaches will always be challenging, but should stimulate new ways of addressing this perennial dilemma. Putting these issues into pragmatic perspective, Jacqui Troughton provides an excellent analysis of current thinking on this subject and concludes with several sensible recommendations. Whatever one's viewpoint, new dietary approaches will always attract interest and controversy. Debate will continue. As with all its associated consequences, diabetes is a great magnifier of what happens in the normal population: unhealthy lifestyle and the consequences are greater; healthy lifestyle and better health outcomes result. Observations across a wide range of animals, including humans, that low calorie but nutritionally balanced diets have the potential to increase lifespan and prolong good health suggest that calorie restriction itself may be more important in delaying the ageing process, but we would probably need to reduce our calorie consumption by at least 30% to be effective. Eating is one of life's pleasures, but do we simply eat too much?

◌ CITATION ONLY
Full text is not openly licensed for redistribution here. Read it at the source:

Read at source →

Provenance

Source
OpenAlex
DOI
10.1002/pdi.475
Canonical
link ↗
Fetched
2026-10-12 MST

Cite this

APA
Shaw, K. (2003). The carbohydrate debate: what is best for patients with diabetes?. <em>Practical Diabetes</em>. https://doi.org/10.1002/pdi.475
Vancouver
Shaw K. The carbohydrate debate: what is best for patients with diabetes?. Practical Diabetes. 2003. doi:10.1002/pdi.475.
BibTeX
@article{ken2003Thecar, title = {The carbohydrate debate: what is best for patients with diabetes?}, author = {Ken Shaw}, journal = {Practical Diabetes}, year = {2003}, doi = {10.1002/pdi.475}, }

Research neighborhood

References, citing works, and semantically nearest findings. Click a node to open it.

Related findings