Skip to content
Preprint via OpenAlex

Sex differences in frailty: the Frailty Index and the male-female health-survival paradox

Emily H Gordon

The University of Queensland · 2020 · ▲ 2 citations

Abstract

BackgroundThe observation that females have poorer health yet live longer than males has long been reported in the scientific literature. Whilst several biological, behavioural and social explanations for sex differences in health and survival have been proposed, the mechanisms underpinning this so-called lmale-female health-survival paradoxr remain unclear. lFrailtyr captures an individualrs vulnerability to a range of adverse outcomes, including death, and may serve as a novel and useful paradigm to explore the sex paradox.nnAims and ObjectivesThe overall aim of this Thesis was to explore the male-female health-survival paradox using the frailty construct. To address this aim, five research objectives were defined:1. To establish whether the male-female health-survival paradox is demonstrated when the Frailty Index (FI) is used as a measure of health status;2. To summarise current knowledge regarding the pathophysiology of sex differences in frailty and the sex-frailty paradox;3. To critically evaluate the chronic disease hypothesis, which is frequently cited as a major contributor to the male-female health-survival paradox;4. To reconsider the chronic disease hypothesis from a frailty and acute illness perspective; and,5. To explore sex differences in the relationship between reproduction and later life frailty.nnMethods and Results The research objectives of this Thesis were addressed through a series of studies:1. A systematic review of observational studies measuring FI and mortality in community-dwellers aged over 65 years of age was conducted. This review identified seven studies representing 19 different countries across the developed and developing world. Meta-analysis of data (N=37,426) confirmed that, in every age group, females had higher FI scores than males. All studies found that females tolerated this frailty better, as demonstrated by a lower mortality rate at any given level of frailty or age. Overall, this systematic review established that the pattern of sex differences in FI and mortality is consistent with the male-female health-survival paradox.2. After reconceptualising the male-female health survival paradox as a lsex-frailty paradoxr, current knowledge regarding biological, behavioural and social explanations for sex differences in morbidity, mortality and frailty were summarized in a narrative review. This review highlighted the issue at the centre of the paradox n that females tolerate poor health (frailty) better than males n and outlinednseveral hypotheses for this phenomenon. At the conclusion of this review, the research objectives for the remainder of the Thesis were identified.3. The chronic disease hypothesis (that males experience more llife-threateningr diseases leading to higher mortality, whereas females experience more lnon-life-threateningr and ldisablingr diseases leading to higher morbidity) was examined in a narrative review. Significant between-study methodological differences were highlighted and frailty was identified as an important covariate and outcome variable to be included in future studies. Overall, this review demonstrated that there is a lack of convincing evidence to support this popular hypothesis. n4. A study to determine whether the sex-frailty paradox is present in hospitalised older adults used interRAI Acute Care Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment data collected from 1,418 hospitalised Australians aged 70 years and over. This study found that even though female inpatients faced a significantly lower risk of near-term mortality, the sexes experienced similar levels of frailty (as measured by an FI) on admission to hospital. Thus, it was proposed that the sex-frailty paradox is a phenomenon unique to heterogeneous, community-dwelling populations. This study also showed that sex differences in mortality risk were not explained by sex differences in the llethalityr of acute medical conditions. This finding contributed to the evidence-base refuting the hypothesis that sex differences in the lethality of diseases underpin the sex paradox. n5. A study investigating the relationship between biological sex, parity and frailty used data collected from 3,534 community-dwellers aged 65 years and older who participated in the English Longitudinal Study of Ageing. This study found that the most parous adults were the most frail (as measured by an FI), providing some evidence for a lparity-frailty trade-offr. However, there was little support for the hypothesis that sex differences in the physiological burden of childbearing contribute greatly to sex differences in later life frailty. Rather, the observation that the relationship between parity and frailty was similar for both sexes suggested that behavioural and social factors associated with childrearing may contribute to the development of frailty in both sexes. nnConclusion This Thesis explored a new perspective on the male-female health-survival paradox. Through a series of published reviews and studies, this Thesis investigated current knowledge regarding the sex-frailty paradox, tested hypotheses regarding sex differences in hospitalised adults with acute illnesses, examined the impact of childbearing on sex differences in frailty, and laid the groundwork for future research. In doing so, this Thesis makes a significant contribution to a research effort that aims to facilitate evidence-based care for ageing men and women. n

◌ CITATION ONLY
Full text is not openly licensed for redistribution here. Read it at the source:

Read at source →

Provenance

Source
OpenAlex
DOI
10.14264/uql.2020.620
Canonical
link ↗
Fetched
2026-10-14 MST

Cite this

APA
Gordon, E.H. (2020). Sex differences in frailty: the Frailty Index and the male-female health-survival paradox. <em>The University of Queensland</em>. https://doi.org/10.14264/uql.2020.620
Vancouver
Gordon EH. Sex differences in frailty: the Frailty Index and the male-female health-survival paradox. The University of Queensland. 2020. doi:10.14264/uql.2020.620.
BibTeX
@unpublished{emily2020Sexdif, title = {Sex differences in frailty: the Frailty Index and the male-female health-survival paradox}, author = {Emily H Gordon}, journal = {The University of Queensland}, year = {2020}, doi = {10.14264/uql.2020.620}, }

Research neighborhood

References, citing works, and semantically nearest findings. Click a node to open it.

Related findings