Citation only
via OpenAlex
Authors' ResponseCorrelation between baseline telomere length and shortening over time—spurious or true?
Anita Kloss‐Brandstätter, Peter Willeit, Claudia Lamina, Stefan Julia Kiechl, Florian Kronenberg
International Journal of Epidemiology · 2010 · ▲ 3 citations
Abstract
Although we do not concur with their conclusions, we very much appreciate the stimulating comments by Erik Giltay et al.1 regarding our previous report2 on the association between baseline telomere(definition) length and subsequent telomere shortening. They argue that the correlation observed in our and in other studies2–4 is mainly due to mathematical coupling and suggest using the correlation due to mathematical coupling as the comparator rather than a correlation coefficient of zero. To enforce their view, Giltay and co-workers have also performed simulation studies with two random variables, X and Y, and then tested the correlation between X and Δ = X − Y. However, this simulation is not appropriate because it ignores that X and Y are repeated measurements in the same individuals and highly correlated (rSpearman = 0.652, P = 4.7 × 10−63).2 Only for two series of independent random numbers X and Y with the same standard deviation, the correlation between X − Y and X expected based on mathematical coupling is indeed as formulated by Giltay et al. (please see Tu and Gilthorpe5 for a comprehensive review). However, as Giltay et al. correctly state, the null hypothesis β = 0 is not a correct null hypothesis any more. Tu and Gilthorpe5 proposed a method for testing the correlation between X and X – Y (). Since this test is based on Pearson’s correlation coefficient, it cannot be seen as a correction for the Spearman’s correlation coefficient, which we presented in the paper, but it is comparable with the P value presented for the linear regression model. The correct null hypothesis can be derived by setting sx = sy. In this case, the Pearson’s correlation coefficient that is only due to mathematical coupling is . If X and Y are not correlated (), then . Therefore, has to be compared with the expected correlation coefficient under the hypothesis of no effect, which is . To make them comparable, Fisher’s z transformation has to be performed. In our data, is clearly higher than the expected correlation coefficient of . The test on Fisher’s z-transformed values yields a value of P = 2.52 x 10−25. In comparison, the crude P value of is P = 1.01 × 10−90. This P value is not adjusted for age, gender and smoking, but since adjustment did not alter the P value of baseline RTL on the change of RTL (adjusted P = 2.3 × 10−90), we can take the corrected unadjusted P value as an approximation of the corrected adjusted P value. To summarize, the reported value of P = 2.3 × 10−90 for the regression of baseline RTL on telomere attrition rate was clearly inflated, but even after correcting this inflation, we still get a value of P = 2.52 x 10−25 for the effect of baseline RTL on the change of RTL. Therefore, this relationship is still highly significant. Accordingly, the strong association between baseline telomere length and telomere attrition does not simply reflect mathematical coupling. It is a true finding that deserves further research efforts and holds promise for unravelling new insights into human cell cycle control and telomere maintenance.
◌ CITATION ONLY
Full text is not openly licensed for redistribution here. Read it at the source:
Provenance
- Source
- OpenAlex
- DOI
- 10.1093/ije/dyq237
- Canonical
- link ↗
- Fetched
- 2026-10-04 MST
Cite this
APA
Kloss‐Brandstätter, A., Willeit, P., Lamina, C., Kiechl, S.J., & Kronenberg, F. (2010). Authors' ResponseCorrelation between baseline telomere length and shortening over time—spurious or true?. <em>International Journal of Epidemiology</em>. https://doi.org/10.1093/ije/dyq237
Vancouver
Kloss‐Brandstätter A, Willeit P, Lamina C, Kiechl SJ, Kronenberg F. Authors' ResponseCorrelation between baseline telomere length and shortening over time—spurious or true?. International Journal of Epidemiology. 2010. doi:10.1093/ije/dyq237.
BibTeX
@article{anita2010Author,
title = {Authors' ResponseCorrelation between baseline telomere length and shortening over time—spurious or true?},
author = {Anita Kloss‐Brandstätter and Peter Willeit and Claudia Lamina and Stefan Julia Kiechl and Florian Kronenberg},
journal = {International Journal of Epidemiology},
year = {2010},
doi = {10.1093/ije/dyq237},
}
Research neighborhood
References, citing works, and semantically nearest findings. Click a node to open it.
Related findings
Journal of Atherosclerosis and Thrombosis 2017
Open access · CC-BY
Oxidative Stress is Closely Associated with Increased Arterial Stiffness, Especially in Aged Male Smokers without Previous Cardiovascular Events: A Cross-Sectional Study
Experimental Dermatology 2016
Open access · OA
Analysis of telomere length as predictive marker in psoriasis for comorbidities
American Journal of Nephrology 2012
Open access · OA
Association between Kidney Function and Telomere Length: The Heart and Soul Study
npj Aging 2026
Open access · CC-BY
Aging-related transcriptomic signatures associated with recurrence following resection of stage I lung adenocarcinoma
Royal Society Open Science 2019
Open access · CC-BY
Controlling for baseline telomere length biases estimates of the rate of telomere attrition
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research) 2019
Preprint · CC-BY